danmusician wrote:What follows is a my reply to Ojustaboo last July as we discussed what Korg should do with Kronos stock already in the pipeline:
At the time I was responding simply in the impression I got from the majority of Kronos owners on this forum.
I have no choice but repeat myself.
3 months later I purchased my own Kronos
It was a new 88 picked directly from Korg UKs warehouse on 1st October 2012 (I received it on the 4th October)
When I placed the order I stressed to the store that I didn't want one that's been hanging around for a while because of the keyboard problem hence they went out of their way to order a new one directly from Korg.
I emailed Korg and spoke to someone about the upgrade they were doing on the new Kronos that PMT Norwich had just ordered from them.
I asked them to check the contacts at time of doing the upgrade and if they had the old ones, to upgrade the contacts before it was sent out to me.
Korg UK said (in my own words so as not to quote their email but nothings exaggerated or added)
You don't have any need for concern, all our stock have the new upgrades
When I received it, on inspection sent Korg the following email on the 5th October 2012
My serial is 2865, someone on Karma Labs forum from the UK has 3249 that they brought before 10th June, I find it odd that new stock has a lower serial number.
You said that all your new stock had the newer contacts, in Korgforums.com it states that the upgraded contacts on the 88 note Kronos start at serial no 3600
On Korg forums it also states the older style contacts are pink and the newer ones are blue. if I shine a torch in the gaps of my keys, they are definitely pink.
I know this sounds a little whiny, I'm sorry I don't mean it to be, I also know some people with the old contacts had no problems.
I am really really happy with it so far, it's just that I paid what is a LOT of money to me to get a brand new Kronos 88 with the updated contacts and if you brought a brand new car which worked perfectly but turned out it wasn't brand new and wasn't what you ordered I suspect you wouldn't be 100% happy either.
I just want to triple check I have received what I paid for?
Korg responded that mine is the one they sent to PMT Norwich and it was fine.
10 days later the keybed problem showed its self after all the effort I'd put in to make sure I had one with the new contacts and all the assurances Korg gave me that it did.
So for the next 7 days I'm without my new £3700 machine.
This cant be compared to the people who waited months for a solution in the first place, this is October 2012, the problem was first being reported around September 2011, the fixes started to be applied in January 2012.
9 months later mine is direct from Korg, I asked them to check it, I was told it was fine, they had the back off in their support department while the upgrade was fixed, I still received one with the old contacts.
Had this been a shop stock one that had been hanging around for a few months, I wouldn't have such a complaint (although I did ask Korg to check the contacts were the new ones at time of upgrade) but to come directly from Korg 13 months after the problem materialised is unacceptable.
The amount of extra time it would take for the engineer to replace the contacts while they are doing the upgrade is next to nothing, the cost to Korg for the strips is pence (a bit like the tact switches, Korg sell them for £1.02 each, or depending on quantity, brought from digi-key, as low as 7p each)
While I understand what you said, for me to receive this board now is totally 100% unacceptable.
What makes it worse is I have the pink contacts and some have been told by Korg US that pink means the old style contacts, yet Korg UK say the opposite.
So one has been misinformed.
So while I'm finally happy, as no official announcement on the colour of the contacts has been made by korg, I honestly wont be surprised in the slightest if in 3 weeks time the problem manifests its self again and I shouldn't have to think like that after having spent this much money.
I can understand them not wanting to do a recall (although I think from a PR point of view it would have saved them thousands long term) but the cost and time involved in opening up any old stock from their warehouse and upgrading the contacts before they are dispatched to stores compared to pissing people like me off, is minuscule and inexcusable.
Tied with the fact that their warranties are non transferable (as is standard practice I know) if I was buying a second hand one with a SN under 3600, if it didn't have the blue contacts, I wouldn't want to buy it and I'm sure I'm not alone, they have also made some of the machines loose a LOT of value for the owner due to a problem that's not the owners fault.
They could have said the warranty isn't transferable with the exception of if the note cut-off happens. But they choose not to.
All the business reasons for not admitting how much of a problem this was fall into insignificance when the Kronos is mentioned on certain forums as a suggestion and others say they wouldn't touch Korg after the way they were dealt with regarding this issue and still others say they wont buy due to all the horror stories they hear.
The problem happened, that doesn't really bother me, unforeseen problems can happen with any new product. But as I and others have said time and time again, it's how a company deals with their customers when a problem happens that tells me how good the company really is, and in this area. Korg has failed badly.
I didn't even consider buying for months due to the keybed problem, but thought by now I was safe to go ahead. Turns out I was wrong
If I'm on this or one of the other piano/keyboard forums and someone mentions the Kronos and the keybed problem and someone else states that was ages ago etc, I will tell them exactly what I experienced this very month and say that from my experience you are still taking a gamble, and point out that Korg Uk and Korg US don't even agree about which ones have the problems (korg US saying pink contacts mean old, korg UK saying they don't). Doesn't look very good does it and it could all have been put to bed months ago.
ps, I agree with the above post from SanderXpander 100%
I think the RH3 is a better action (when it's working properly!) (October 2012)
The Korg Kronos is probably the best synthesizer in the world, however its release revealed many problems and unhappy customers. Following on from the initial problems, there are still problems with the keybeds (July 2012)
I was actually quite impressed with the RH3 ("Made in Japan") keybed but maybe that's me coming to it from the Stage rather than the RD700GX. Unfortunately, within literally seconds I was able to replicate the keybed cut-off error. (June 2012)
I get that its supposed to be the all singing all dancing eight wonder of the world, but Ive watched enough videos on youtube by disenchanted Kronos owners to know that a $200 discount is not going to compensate for Korg’s lack of quality control. Malfunctioning keybeds...(July 31st 2012)
The second one I get, one year after first ordering, and the keyboard still has the note cut-off and key bounce problems (28th April 2012)
Edit: spelling