I am looking at adding to my collection and been eying off the Prologue at my local store, but I have heard the new Minilogue XD might be better?
Has anyone played with the XD yet, and if so what is the feel like compared to the Prologue?
VS
Descision Time
Moderators: Sharp, X-Trade, Pepperpotty, karmathanever
Descision Time
Hi Guys,
I am looking at adding to my collection and been eying off the Prologue at my local store, but I have heard the new Minilogue XD might be better?
Has anyone played with the XD yet, and if so what is the feel like compared to the Prologue?
VS
I am looking at adding to my collection and been eying off the Prologue at my local store, but I have heard the new Minilogue XD might be better?
Has anyone played with the XD yet, and if so what is the feel like compared to the Prologue?
VS
Kidding? why should it be better?
Analogue board is most likely the same (the filter is different), digital osc and fx are exactly the same, yeah you can have delay and reverb simultaneously.
but 16 voices vs 4 voices, how 4 can sound better than 16 if you need 5 voices to play chord? Or layer sounds?
yes there are some improvements on digital side, in fact they have to push sales somehow
Analogue board is most likely the same (the filter is different), digital osc and fx are exactly the same, yeah you can have delay and reverb simultaneously.
but 16 voices vs 4 voices, how 4 can sound better than 16 if you need 5 voices to play chord? Or layer sounds?
yes there are some improvements on digital side, in fact they have to push sales somehow
Korg R3, EMX1, volca keys, minikp 2, electribe 2, prologue, karp oddy, dns 12, all ios apps.
Re: Descision Time
Depends what you need!benraw88 wrote:Hi Guys,
I am looking at adding to my collection and been eying off the Prologue at my local store, but I have heard the new Minilogue XD might be better?
Has anyone played with the XD yet, and if so what is the feel like compared to the Prologue?
The Prologue seems to have been designed purely for players that want full size keyboard, and does feel very substantial and nice quality.
The Minilogue XD has fewer voices than either Prologue, and a couple of things not there like sustain on the assignable EG, but practically speaking it should sound identical to Prologue. It is still nice quality, with steel shaft pots ringed to the chassis (no wiggles), but just doesnt have the heft that Prologue does.
For me (mostly doing electronica) I personally find the XD a much superior machine as it has the microtonal sequencer with 4 tracks of parameter automation, and also 2 CV inputs so can create more detailed sounds when using external CV modulation sources.
I guess it really depends on your purposes.
I do both play live and sequence prologue.
As a live player I need more voices and bi-timbrality is a very important not only for layered sounds or split, but I can assign different midi channels and run bass sequence while playing pads for example.
I have no issues with sequencing either cause I just run it form Octatrack that has 4 extra lfos per midi track and can p-lock up to 10 parameters so i am not really impressed by the sequencer form XD. However for those who have no proper sequencer but still want to run sequences and mono-timbrality with lesser voices are not issues I believe minilogue XD is a good option.
Summarizing:
Prologue - full sized keys, more voices, bi-timbrality, proper adsr, some more options in voice management (like mono mode), very nice patch management
Minilogue XD - sequencer, price, 3 effects simultaneously
I do both play live and sequence prologue.
As a live player I need more voices and bi-timbrality is a very important not only for layered sounds or split, but I can assign different midi channels and run bass sequence while playing pads for example.
I have no issues with sequencing either cause I just run it form Octatrack that has 4 extra lfos per midi track and can p-lock up to 10 parameters so i am not really impressed by the sequencer form XD. However for those who have no proper sequencer but still want to run sequences and mono-timbrality with lesser voices are not issues I believe minilogue XD is a good option.
Summarizing:
Prologue - full sized keys, more voices, bi-timbrality, proper adsr, some more options in voice management (like mono mode), very nice patch management
Minilogue XD - sequencer, price, 3 effects simultaneously
Korg R3, EMX1, volca keys, minikp 2, electribe 2, prologue, karp oddy, dns 12, all ios apps.
I know its part of the sequencing but the addition of motion sequencing is also a major creative bonus (even without sequencer notes can be used as modulation stepped or smoothed source), and the all new CV inputs.NickZoll wrote:
Minilogue XD - sequencer, price, 3 effects simultaneously
CV inputs allow the XD to be sequenced by typical CV/gate sequencers, or can use both CV inputs as modulation sources to any destination - ie can be an additional 2 LFOs, or envelopes, etc... For users like me that have CV equipment (even something like Korg SQ1) and/or eurorack this really allows the XD to be brought into the fold.
I agree with you mod seq is a nice touch, probably not essential for daw based producers or people with proper hardware sequencer but still nice to have
One extra cv is also a good bonus, in fact I also have some eurorack stuff but I find it easier to adjust lfos from my octa rather cv expression port cause it is just much more intuitive with midi learn function.
I am not quite sure whether it gives a lot to have 2 cv ports in terms of sequencing cause you vould have to use one for pitch control and second for triggering giving up extra lfos, midi sequencing makes more sense in this respect to me.
In general I think I get your point that xd is a bit better equipped for sequencing and working with external gear right of the box.
One extra cv is also a good bonus, in fact I also have some eurorack stuff but I find it easier to adjust lfos from my octa rather cv expression port cause it is just much more intuitive with midi learn function.
I am not quite sure whether it gives a lot to have 2 cv ports in terms of sequencing cause you vould have to use one for pitch control and second for triggering giving up extra lfos, midi sequencing makes more sense in this respect to me.
In general I think I get your point that xd is a bit better equipped for sequencing and working with external gear right of the box.
Korg R3, EMX1, volca keys, minikp 2, electribe 2, prologue, karp oddy, dns 12, all ios apps.
My first Prologue was an 8 voice. What I then detected very soon, was that the nice splitting and layering functions work much better with the full 16 voices available. And if you seriously want to use the digital ascillators along with the analog ones, I think a four voice instrument would be a really poor choice (unless you only use extremely limited voicings all the time, and have no need for full polyphonic use).
All in all I think Korg's decision to give the low price synth some remarkable pluses over their much more expensive "flagship" synth (like motion sequencer and a richer effect section) is an utterly poor company design decision.
If they don't update at least a part of the additional functionality in the Prologue OS - and do that very soon - they will annoy customers on both sides with weird limitations:
- on the Minilogue XD side with a to me completely unacceptable crippled EG, and too few voices to be able to enjoy the additional digital OSC enough.
- and on the Prologue side it's even worse, with seriously (!!!) offering less effects and movement abilities (motion sequencer) to customers paying flagship prices.
This way they achieve what has widely been nicknamed "a Roland" in recent times, for good reason: offering weird mixtures of benefits and utterly crappy shortcomings in funny board design decisions. Roland hoped to sell more units, because customers would have to buy lots of their gear to get all the goodies. In fact they lost many customers that way (I alone know enough, who left Roland behind altogether for exactly that reason).
If the present Korg management is keen to annoy and alienate more customers the whack Roland way, this is definitely the way to go!
All in all I think Korg's decision to give the low price synth some remarkable pluses over their much more expensive "flagship" synth (like motion sequencer and a richer effect section) is an utterly poor company design decision.
If they don't update at least a part of the additional functionality in the Prologue OS - and do that very soon - they will annoy customers on both sides with weird limitations:
- on the Minilogue XD side with a to me completely unacceptable crippled EG, and too few voices to be able to enjoy the additional digital OSC enough.
- and on the Prologue side it's even worse, with seriously (!!!) offering less effects and movement abilities (motion sequencer) to customers paying flagship prices.
This way they achieve what has widely been nicknamed "a Roland" in recent times, for good reason: offering weird mixtures of benefits and utterly crappy shortcomings in funny board design decisions. Roland hoped to sell more units, because customers would have to buy lots of their gear to get all the goodies. In fact they lost many customers that way (I alone know enough, who left Roland behind altogether for exactly that reason).
If the present Korg management is keen to annoy and alienate more customers the whack Roland way, this is definitely the way to go!
Kronos 73 - Moog Voyager RME - Moog LP TE - Behringer Model D - Prophet 6 - Roland Jupiter Xm - Rhodes Stage 73 Mk I - Elektron Analog Rytm MkII - Roland TR-6s - Cubase 12 Pro + Groove Agent 5
I also do not understand what made them to provide more advanced firmware for minilogue xd, I am guessing they expect plenty of the units. As one of the first prologue users I am quite upset... But reasonably because it is still a beautiful synth with 11000 discrete components. I do not think they would implement 3 simultaneous effects for prologue due to control limitations. They may provide us with a sequencer but it is less likely in my opinion. I may be too pessimistic but I do not think they would give any further update to prologue just maybe bug fixes 
Korg R3, EMX1, volca keys, minikp 2, electribe 2, prologue, karp oddy, dns 12, all ios apps.
Still, Radias has 4 LFO, 24 voices, motion sequencing, 4 part multitimbral, variable filter plus lots more that Prologue/Minilogue doesnt. Also IMO the Radias/R3/MicroKORG XL destroys MS2000/MicroKORG in fidelity.NickZoll wrote:i do not know whether you need it but I had radias and I have prologue that sounds much more superior.
In fact there is no sense to compare noisy va from mid 2000s and a real analog beast
Horses for courses again!
I don't think it makes much sense to compare the (of course!) bigger functionality of VAs with that of analogue synths. This point is clear from the start.
Still, there must be a reason, why many musicians decide against higher functionality to prefer an anlog synth, even if with just one LFO, no? I certainly can answer that for my part: I couldn't care less for a Radias (which I DO regard as a nice VA), when I can use an analog synth like the Prophet 6 or the Prologue instead. That's because, for most purposes except a few, the basic sonic character of a synth is ten times more important to me than 4 LFOs could ever be.
But that's a decision of personal preferences, and it's up to everyone to decide for themslves.
Still, there must be a reason, why many musicians decide against higher functionality to prefer an anlog synth, even if with just one LFO, no? I certainly can answer that for my part: I couldn't care less for a Radias (which I DO regard as a nice VA), when I can use an analog synth like the Prophet 6 or the Prologue instead. That's because, for most purposes except a few, the basic sonic character of a synth is ten times more important to me than 4 LFOs could ever be.
But that's a decision of personal preferences, and it's up to everyone to decide for themslves.
Kronos 73 - Moog Voyager RME - Moog LP TE - Behringer Model D - Prophet 6 - Roland Jupiter Xm - Rhodes Stage 73 Mk I - Elektron Analog Rytm MkII - Roland TR-6s - Cubase 12 Pro + Groove Agent 5
Absolutely agree on that, radias is just a noisy infant comparing to prologue.
Prologue sounds way cleaner. Still radias is one of my fav va synths, sometimes I even miss it cause I spent 8 years with radias
Prologue sounds way cleaner. Still radias is one of my fav va synths, sometimes I even miss it cause I spent 8 years with radias
Korg R3, EMX1, volca keys, minikp 2, electribe 2, prologue, karp oddy, dns 12, all ios apps.